Categories: News

AEC – Another rushed education policy not based on research, evidence or consultation

The Aotearoa Educator's Collective warns that recent policy changes to curriculum are not based on sound research.

Recently, we saw an announcement of a new plan for mathematics education, apparently in response to what Prime Minister Christopher Luxon describes as a “total system failure” in teaching mathematics.

This reponse is based on the 2023 results of the Curriculum Insights and Progress study, a yearly national monitoring approach that replaces the previous cycles of national monitoring of all learning areas (NMSSA). 

Read the latest print edition of School News HERE

Both the Prime Minister and Education Minister have stated that this study shows that only 22% of students are working at or above the expected curriculum level for Year 8 students. The result of around only one in five students working at the curriculum level in Year 8 seems questionable given it contradicts previous national and international studies, including NMSSA, TIMMS, and PISA, which all show higher levels of student achievement. 

The release of this assessment information today shows that it is not reflective of a drastic drop in achievement but instead a change in the benchmarking being used. These results have been benchmarked to the refreshed curriculum (Sept 2023), and not to the current New Zealand Curriculum document (2007) that is being taught. 

The purpose of the refreshed curriculum is to realign learning that will be strengthened, starting in the first 3 years, which would then increase expectations of what would be learned by Year 8. The original implementation of the refreshed curriculum was to begin in 2026, with a logical expectation that, as students moved through the school years, their maths achievement would be advancing. Year 1 students starting with the refreshed curriculum in 2026 would be in Year 8 in 2033. We question the use of data based on assessments where student tasks are based on a curriculum that is not being taught. 

The coalition government is currently revising the Sept 2023 version of the maths curriculum. The document has not yet been released for consultation from the sector. Yet, further changes have been announced which are being rushed through and implemented next year, creating extra pressure on our teachers. The announcement referenced teacher guidebooks and student workbooks being developed by an unknown publisher. There has been no information provided on how these are being developed and tested and no assurance that these resources will be culturally appropriate of contextually suitable for ākonga across Aotearoa. 

A one size fits all mandated approach ignores the diversity in our country and fails to take account of the excellent research and practice that can be found here in Aotearoa. Instead of a rushed curriculum and an untested commercial textbook scheme, we call for investment in our greatest resource – our teachers. 

Professor Jodie Hunter, Massey University – AEC Spokesperson
Associate Professor Naomi Ingram, University of Otago
Dr Jane McChesney, University of Canterbury
Dr Lisa Darragh, University of Auckland
Dr Jyoti Jhagroo, Auckland University of Technology
Louise Fitzgerald, Massey University
School News

School News is not affiliated with any government agency, body or political party. We are an independently owned, family-operated magazine.

Recent Posts

English curriculum draft out for consultation

The much-delayed English draft curriculum is now out for consultation, generating discussion from teachers.

2 weeks ago

Arts, culture and recreation positive for the wellbeing of rangatahi

Research from AUT demonstrates arts, culture and recreation have positive impacts on all aspects of…

2 weeks ago

School phone ban one year on: our student survey reveals mixed feelings about its success

How effective has the school phone ban been in achieving its aims? Researchers from the…

2 weeks ago

Learning growing and exploring with school camps and excursions

School camps and excursions deliver hands on learning experiences, helping to consolidate classroom learning.

2 weeks ago

Could an AV system improve learning outcomes and student engagement?

Innovations in AV technologies present new opportunities to engage with students. We look at how…

2 weeks ago

What makes a good teacher?

A new report from the University of Auckland’s Our Voices Project asks young people what…

3 weeks ago